Email Google Meta

Sitka Salmon Shares

MuteSix worked with the seafood subscription service to increase reach and purchases by expanding into new locations with Facebook, Google and Email marketing.

Purchases Increase with Facebook
Conversions Increase with Google
Revenue Increase YoY with Email

The Overview

Sitka Salmon Shares is an ocean to doorstep seafood subscription service. They deliver responsible, fresh, wild-caught Alaskan salmon from a collective of small-boat fishermen across Alaska and the Midwest. Sitka first came to MuteSix as they were bringing their business digital to develop a go-to-market strategy that would generate purchases and improve retention. After achieving great success with our go-to-market strategy, Sitka set a new goal to reach a wider audience by expanding targeting into new locations in the lower 48 states.

The Strategy

Given the higher costs for performance due to privacy mandate changes on Facebook in 2021, we realized the best way for Sitka to scale and reach more people was to expand targeting.

Our biggest challenge was getting consumers to commit to a subscription during the “off season” from January to March, as the season for fresh fish delivery is from April to December. To combat this challenge, the brand implemented a “try before you buy” option that offered consumers one-off subscription boxes, so they could try fish without committing to a full-priced subscription.

In our Facebook ads, we generated a sense of urgency by creating “Last Chance” banners focused on convincing consumers to order a subscription box for that specific month. We also produced high intent videos for top of funnel targeting to educate new consumers about the quality of Sitka’s fish and the fishermen behind the brand. We saw success by utilizing strong user generated content, “food porn” style cooking videos, 5 reasons why call outs, and solid intro videos.

The Paid Search team’s highest priority was to drive purchases at Sitka’s target CPA of $100. To achieve this goal, we launched a dynamic search ad campaign with a low budget targeting all webpages. We optimized the campaign’s performance by writing three compelling ad copy variations for the ad group, and as a result, the DSA campaign became the solution for the acquisition funnel on Google, driving consistent conversions on a week-by-week basis at a $70 CPA. 

Our biggest goal for Sitka’s email marketing is to promote their “local, small company feel,” while exponentially growing their business and maintaining above average engagement metrics. While their campaigning is mostly managed in-house, Sitka relies on the MuteSix email marketing experts to provide best practices for growing their business. 

Sitka sends nearly 70-80 campaigns a month, with highly targeted messaging, to a variety of hyper focused segments. We focus our strategy on automations, analytics, reporting, design, branding, best practices for campaign sends, and special campaign needs for their sales and community management. We also focus our efforts on growing Sitka’s list size, targeting consumers with pop ups and banners on their site, and optimizing Sitka’s Welcome Series, Browse Abandon, and Post Purchase – and soon to include Abandoned Cart since Sitka has fully transitioned over to Shopify. Our cross-channel tactics work in tandem to increase Sitka’s subscriber base by targeting users throughout their journey, and ultimately, converting them into full-fledged subscription holders.


Increase in Spend on Facebook
Purchases Increase via Facebook
Decrease in CPA on Facebook
CVR on Facebook


Decrease in CPA on Google
Increase in Spend on Google
Increase in Conversions on Google
Increase in CTR on Google
Increase in ROAS on Google


Average Open Rate for Email
Average Click Rate on Email
In Revenue Attributed to Email within 1 year
Increase in Revenue YoY from Email
List Growth for Email

Interested in Working Together?

Let’s Get Started